LinkedIn

Wednesday, June 26, 2013

Every Industrial Hygienist should be a Modeler

If you are a practicing Industrial Hygienist (IH) you are a Risk Assessor.   You compare measured or estimated exposures to exposure limits and this activity characterizes or assesses the risk.   You typically do not develop exposure limits but you do estimate, measure other otherwise gauge the level of actual exposure to the agent in question.   We do this mostly with inhalation exposure.  When we actually measure and we do it by measuring the concentration of the agent in the potential breathing zone of the worker and, as mentioned before, comparing it to an occupational exposure limit (OEL) with the same units of concentration and the same time frame.  Thus the stock-in-trade of the IH is exposure estimation to be used in the context of risk assessment .

It has been well shown that the vast majority of occupational exposures are NOT measured but they are estimated using EXPERT JUDGEMENT.   Clearly the industrial hygienists are running some algorithm (that is a MODEL) subconsciously  in their mind that either concludes that the risk is insignificant or in need or further evaluation.   Explaining “expert judgment” has always proven to be very difficult. Some are better at invoking this hidden process than others. Indeed, the more experience you have as an industrial hygienist, the more you test or validate your subconscious models versus reality and the more skilled you become.


My point is that as tool-using animals, we are much better off if, as industrial hygienists, we raise the models we use to the level of consciousness so that we might be able to enjoy the following advantages over the subliminal approach. The critical advantages of separate and explicit exposure models include their inherent ability to be
  • Examined by the modeler and others in a critical review of their work or use
  • Explained to folks with a stake in the prediction and outcome 
  • Applied retrospectively (estimating past exposures)
  • Shared and passed on as technology transfer (education of the next generation)
  • Tested (validated) and improved using the scientific method  
When you learn and use exposure models you identify yourself as a technologist, someone who uses science to answer questions.  You enhance your standing with your employer and your charges.  You distance yourself from the characterization as a "Pump Jockey".   From a professional development perspective, becoming a modeler is well worth the effort.

Learning and using models is not simple but it is not impossible either.  I have found it is best to progress with  baby steps.  Start with relatively simply models, which I have found to be remarkably useful, and then progress to more sophisticated and detailed tools which are even more valuable.   There are lots of free software tools out their and some good educational material.   Depending on the response I get to this blog I may dedicate the next one or two to being more specific about these opportunities and resources.


Wednesday, June 12, 2013

Describing Uncertainty

Uncertainty is everywhere.   Indeed, there is not a thing or quantity that we can measure that does not have some level of uncertainty.  For example, the length of any "standard" length object for measuring 1 yard (i.e., a yard stick) is not exactly 1 yard (except by definition) - there is always some finite  tolerance + or - (however small) around the 1 yard mark.  We cannot be completely certain about any measurement.   Measurement tolerance is one form of uncertainty.  Quantities that vary naturally are another form.  For example, the weight of all adult females in Pennsylvania will have some variation and therefore the weight of any PA female adult with fall within a range of uncertainty.  Indeed, any individual will have weight that varies over time.  The other source of uncertainty, which is typically the most important and dominant, in risk assessment is a lack of information associated with the value of interest.   I am going to use the weight of my dog Libby in an attempt to show the interaction between natural variation and lack of knowledge.   In this whimsical example let us assume that Libby's weight is an important value in a risk assessment and if we overestimate her weight we overestimate the risk.   Similarly, if we underestimate her weight we underestimate the risk.   How much does Libby weigh? 
When I pose this question to students they usually ask me to identify Libby's breed.   I tell them that I will only disclose to them that Libby is a pure bred dog and is fully grown.   I tell them that they all have some information about the universe of dog weights on Earth.  At that point, the students usually present a range of weights to represent Libby, for example 5-200 lbs.  This implies that there is no chance Libby could weigh less than 5 or more than 200 lbs. (Worst case estimated weight as risk surrogate = 200 lbs).  I then tell them that Libby is an English Springer Spaniel.   Those with online-capable phones might find that female Springer's typically weigh between 35 and 45 lbs.   The students could choose 35-45 lbs as the new range of estimated weights, one born of more information but some will remember the condition that if we specifically underestimate Libby's weight we underestimate the risk.   These wise students then may (and have) come up with an estimated range of 35 to 70 lbs.  The next step might be to go to my home and look into the window of our garage (where Libby is) to see her.   Such an examination will disclose an overweight dog perhaps as much as 20-30 lbs overweight.  The new estimated range from these observations might be 55-70 lbs.  The final step might be to go into my garage and weigh Libby daily over the period of a month.  Here the data might show her to weight to vary between 62-64 lbs. This range is now a much better data-based estimate of lowest to highest which reflects the natural variation of her weight while all the previous estimates were plagued by a greater lack of knowledge.   Forced to make a deterministic (single value) estimate of her weight one might use 65 lbs to guard against getting her on a day when she ate or retained somewhat more than normal.   
The point here is that we could ALWAYS provide some useful quantitative estimate of Libby's weight and the uncertainty around it even when the available data was meager.  The estimate got better (more useful) with more data.
Just to stretch this analogy even further.   What if I said I have an animal in my garage and I will not tell you what species of animal but you need to estimate its weight as proportional to risk!   Here the uncertainty born of ignorance is MUCH greater and the 40 fold range of estimated weight above.  Indeed, given such a large range one might rightly question the utility of the estimate but the point remains that the uncertainty at any stage of the assessment should be estimated and disclosed.  Such uncertainly analysis shows where we might get the best bang for our data buck - in this case knowing what animal species is in the garage. That specific information would then allow us to make much more narrow and a more useful estimation of the range of weight as a surrogate for risk. 

Wednesday, June 5, 2013

Uncertainty is the Bane of the Risk Assessment Process

Almost 20 years ago I had the privilege of presenting testimony before the President’s Commission on Risk Assessment.  I used that opportunity to describe and bemoan the relative nascent state-of-the-science and how uncertainties in both the toxicology and exposure assessment of risk assessment were really limiting the utility and ultimately the credibility of the process.   A measure of our progress might be seen in fact that the title of that talk and the title of this week’s blog are identical.   That talk from almost 20 years ago goes into the subject in a lot more detail.   If any of you reading this ask me for it I will send you the PowerPoint slides from that presentation (mjayjock@gmail.com).

This is not to say that no progress have been made; indeed, a lot has happened in twenty years on the exposure side of things.   Some really great tools have been developed by the volunteers within the American Industrial Hygiene Association which have been made generally available as books and freeware.    Go to:
to get some of these models and go to the AIHA Press:  https://webportal.aiha.org/Purchase/SearchCatalog.aspx
to see the books on Exposure Assessment Strategies, Risk Assessment Principles and Mathematical Modeling.   Even with these tools a ton of work still needs to happen on the exposure side of risk to reduce the uncertainty; however, I must say that we have come a long way.

From my perspective, even more work needs to happen in toxicology.   Clearly, advanced techniques have been developed but from my perspective, available data that provides confident information on what is happening in human tissue at environmentally relevant concentrations of chemical exposure has not happened.   Most of the current occupational exposure limits (OELs) are based on the current toxicity base which uses the responses of animals at high doses in order to estimate relatively “safe” or allowable levels of exposure to humans at relatively low exposure.     See previous blogs for a more detailed discussion of this subject.

So what might be done with all this uncertainty?   Is the risk assessment process so laden with uncertainty as to be worthless?  I think not.  Indeed, at almost any level, a rational assessment of the health risk posed by chemical exposure is better than not doing it.   For me, the challenge is appropriately describing that uncertainty for the various stakeholders in the process.    Indeed, the suitable description of uncertainty would hopefully point the way to its reduction.   

Properly handed using the upper end of the uncertainty – for example, the 95th upper bound percentile -as the measure of risk will reasonably bias the analysis toward overestimating and not underestimating the risk.   Thus, if one is able to shrink the range of uncertainty (with more data) the 95th percentile upper bound will come down as well which means we are properly trading data for conservatism in the spirit of a precautionary approach.

For many years I used Monte Carlo uncertainty analysis for the assessment of risk which allows for everyone to see the specific uncertainty that exists and feeds the various parts of the assessment.   It gives the stakeholders a good view of where the uncertainties exist and how additional information might truly help the evaluation and the subsequent decisions.   This and a simpler form of uncertainty analysis will the subject of a future blog.

Given the level of uncertainty in our current set of OELs, my suggestion is that we quantitative describe the uncertainty within these values as part of the documentation of any OEL.    Doing so will typically reveal a relatively large range of uncertainty which some may find disconcerting; however, I believe that disclosing it is a critical part of the integrity of the process.   More about this critical issue of documenting OELs will happen in a future blog as well.   




Wednesday, May 29, 2013

WE ALLOW WORKERS TO BEAR MUCH MORE CHEMICAL RISK THAN THE GENERAL PUBLIC

Last week I discussed the fact that for most chemicals (i.e., those NOT identified as carcinogens) quantitative risk at any exposure including the exposure limit is NOT estimated as part of any documentation describing the toxicity of those chemicals. In the case of identified carcinogens, however, a quantitative level of risk IS estimated such that some finite risk is assigned for every exposure down to zero. The “allowable” exposure for members of the general public is often set at around 1 in 100,000 or 1 in 1,000,000 extra or additional risk of getting cancer during a lifetime of exposure at this level.   The “acceptable” level set for occupational exposures to carcinogens is typically set at exposure limits which render an estimated risk around 1 in 1,000 extra or additional risk of cancer.  The natural questions are:  Where did the one in 1,000 come from?  Why is there such a large difference between workers and the general public?  Shouldn't we be just as protective of workers as we are members of the general public?   The answers are interesting and the subject of this week’s blog.

The conventional wisdom is that the 1 in 1,000 number came out of the US Supreme Court decision on the carcinogenic risk assessment and statutory (OSHA) exposure limit for benzene.  Considering a 1 in a billion risk Justice Steven’s wrote that it “clearly could not be considered significant”.   One the other hand, he offered that a one in a thousand risk of dying from inhaling vapors containing benzene “might well” be considered significant (emphasis added).   

Hence the 1 in a 1,000 level of putative risk became the de facto standard for occupational carcinogens.   It turns out that the level of actuarial risk of death from occupational or on-the-job injury in the United States is somewhat higher.   See the table below which is perhaps 10 year old data from the US Bureau of Labor Statistics.  These are the actuarial working lifetime risk of death per thousand in various job classifications:

  • All private industry                             --              2.1
  • Manufacturing                                    --              1.6
  • Mining                                                 --            10.8
  • Construction                                       --               5.9
  • Finance                                               --               0.6
  • Commercial Fishing                            --             61
Readers who have watched "The Deadliest Catch" on TV will appreciate the last entry.

From my perspective, a putative risk at 1 in 1,000 for cancer using a linear dose response model described in my previous blogs fits in reasonably well with these actuarial risks. Other reason that folks have given to rationalize a higher risk for workers than the general public includes the fact that workers are normally healthier than individuals in the general populations which includes very old, very young and some critically and chronically ill individuals.   Another factor that is not typically stated but perhaps implied is that workers are deriving some financial benefit from their exposure and should thus bear some higher level risk.    Whatever the reason, the difference appears to be well inculcated as a societal norm at least in the US.  

The "gut check" for me is whether I would allow or advise my son or daughter to be occupationally exposed at any such an exposure limit - that is, an exposure that would present a putative risk of 1 in 1,000.    The answer to that question depends on the data and model used to make that determination.   Given a reasonable data set, model and a clear toxicological rationale by the experts, I would.   The problem is that these elements are often not present - which will be a topic included in next week's blog.

Next week's blog will be "Uncertainty is the Bane of the Risk Assessment Process".

Friday, May 24, 2013

We do not estimate Quantitative Risk for Most Chemicals


In last week’s blog I discussed the difference between calculated actuarial risk and the risk we estimate using the risk  assessment of chemicals.   I mentioned that instead of actuarial risk which is born of historical response (e.g., deaths from auto accidents) that the estimated health risk from our exposure to chemicals is not calculated in this manner and is not nearly as accurate.  Indeed, most of the time it is not calculated at all.   At that point I did not explain any further but promised to get back to you.    Well here is the further explanation.
We have tested relatively few chemicals for their ability to cause cancer (carcinogenicity).   The reason for this is that it is very expensive (millions $)  to test rats or mice for a majority of their life span by housing and exposing them to the chemical every day or most days and then killing and studying their body tissues at the end of the study.   I had a professor who told me that about half the chemicals we test for carcinogenicity come out positive.   I have not checked this as a fact but it makes sense to me.   The manner of testing is that you exposed the animals to very high doses on the high end group of the study.   This is the so call Maximum Tolerated Dose (MTD).   A dose that is so high that the animals can just barely tolerate it without dying.   Such doses especially over a lifetime can cause all kinds of reactions in the body.   Even simple irritants can cause the cells of the body to react by reproducing prematurely and in doing so they can make mistakes in the DNA synthesis and produce a cancer.  
Even though it may be quite common when we look for it, we historically treat the identified cancer causing chemicals very differently.    The assumption is that there is no dose without risk (no threshold) and therefore the smallest amount (one molecule) presents some cancer risk and two molecules presents twice this level of risk.   This is the so call linear dose response estimate.   So we have used a linear model to estimate the dose or exposure that gives an “acceptably” low level of risk (a virtually safe dose).   This risk is often the exposure that results in 1 in 1,000,000 estimated additional cancer risk for members of the general public but about 1 in 1000 for workers.   I hope to get into the reasons for this difference in “allowable risk” in the next blog but for now it’s enough to see that we estimate a quantitative level of risk for any exposure to an identified or declared carcinogen.  
Most chemicals are not considered to be carcinogens but they are known to cause some bad health effect (e.g., liver , kidney or nervous system toxicity) given high enough dose.   Historically we do not treat non-carcinogens in the same manner.   Indeed, the conventional wisdom is that there is some threshold of exposure below which NOTHING bad happens.   Here we set “acceptable” exposure as the level that did not cause a bad effect in an animal study divided by an uncertainty or a safety factor.    The critical piece here is the assumption that a threshold exists.   The way risk is estimated is that the estimated exposure (EXP)  to the chemical is compared to the allowable exposure limit  (EL) as a ratio:   EXP/EL  =  Hazard Index (HI).    If the HI is less than 1 then everyone is happy.   If it is greater than 1 then something has to be done to control the risk.   Please note that in this scheme there is NO quantitative estimate of the risk at the exposure limit or any fraction of the limit.

For many years I would argue with my colleagues in toxicology that most thresholds cannot be proven because of limitations in our methodology.   My argument was that we should estimate the quantitative level of risk for all chemicals including non-carcinogens at and below their exposure limit or the level of “acceptable” exposure.    I wrote a paper about this in 2001 with two colleagues that was largely ignored.     More recently (2009) the 'National Academy of Sciences (NAS) published the so called “Silver Book” which basically agrees with me that the distinction between carcinogens and non-carcinogens is not valid and that the quantitative level of risk should be estimated for all.   The NAS now offers all its books as free PDFs for 'download.   If you are interested in getting this book go to:  http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=12209
Chapter 5 is where the action is on this topic.

I will be happy to send anyone a PDF our 2001 paper if you send me an email request:  mjayjock@gmail.com

So far the occupational health community has continued to successfully ignore this issue and continues to not estimate quantitative levels of risk for non-carcinogens.
Next time I will discuss the difference between exposure limits for workers and the general public.

 

Tuesday, May 14, 2013

Actuarial Risk versus the Risk Estimated from Our Chemical Exposure

Actuarial Risk is very different from the risk to human health that we estimate from chemical exposure.    Indeed, actuarial risk is pretty straightforward.   It is simply the historical risk of an activity with the assumption that the present and near future will be like the past.  Let's look at the risk of traffic accidents. About 35,000 American died in traffic accidents in 2010 (the last year I could easily find with complete data).  One might predict from this that about that many would died again in 2011 and 2012.   Given a 75 year lifetime this is a lifetime risk of about 1 in 150.   In reality this risk, for a number of reasons that I will not go into, has come down steadily in the last 40 years or so.  This actual risk was about 1/65 in 1969.  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:U.s._traffic_deaths_as_fraction_of_total_popualtion_1900-2010.png)

This is actuarial risk and given the numbers it is easy to calculate and from year to year is pretty accurate for systems that change slowly.  Insurance companies rely heavily on this to set premiums in a effort to be competitive and to assure that they will remain profitable.

The estimated risk from our exposure to chemicals is not calculated in this manner and is not nearly as accurate. Indeed, most of the time it is not calculated at all.  But forgive me, I am getting ahead of myself. The very important topic of calculating the risk to exposure to non-carcinogenic chemical will be a matter for another blog.  Here I will talk about the calculated or estimated human risk of getting cancer from exposure to a chemical suspected to cause cancer at least in animals.   The standard manner of testing a chemical for its ability to cause cancer is to expose separate groups of animals (perhaps 20-50 rats or mice in each group) to high levels of the chemical for a majority of their lifetime (typically 2 years) with the highest dose designed to be so toxic as to be the highest dose the animals can tolerate without quickly dying from it.  This is called the Maximum Tolerated Dose (MTD) for the highest group and then perhaps 2 or 3 groups at fractions of this dose with the hope that a least the lowest dose will result in a No Observed Adverse Effect Level (NOAEL).    At the end of the study the animals are killed and surgically examined very carefully by a pathologist for any signs of cancer in their tissues.   Say that 10 out of 20 in the MTD group got a certain tumor then the response would be 50%.     Typically the lower dose groups will, as expected, give lower response rates and the NOAEL will have a response rate that is indistinguishable from control rats that were treated the same but without exposure to the chemical.  In reality the NOAEL dose would have resulted in 3-20% response if a much larger number of rats than 20-50 had been tested.

Now comes the magic.   We are not interested in an exposure that gives 10% or even 1% risk.  This is simply too high.   We want to know what the exposure is that results in a risk of 1 in a million or 1 in 100,000 for members of the general public. For workers we often look upon a much higher risk  as "not unacceptable" but we are sticking here in our example with the general public .   In order to estimate this level of risk one needs to apply a mathematical model to fit the data and do what is known as low dose extrapolation based on the model.   The problem is that there are many models that fit the known data but give very different estimated exposures for 1 in 1,000,000 risk.   As a result the estimated risk at any exposure that people might actually be exposed to can vary by a hundred or even more than a thousand fold.   The EPA has adopted a model that it uses to do this extrapolation but it can be argued that this model and indeed all the other models are arguments without data.   We simply do not know what is happening to human tissues as a result of any low exposure level nor do we know the actual risk posed at these low levels.  The risk predicted by these models at these environmentally relevant exposures are not actual risk they are putative risk.

A model-predicted risk of 1 in 1,000,000 for the pesticides in the salads we eat does not mean that one in million (between 300-350 folks in the US) will get cancer in their lifetime from eating their salad.   The number may be zero or even a negative number (i.e., protection from cancer) depending on which model one uses for low dose extrapolation.   I know it may be intriguing but I am also leaving negative risk at low dose as another topic for a future blog.  Its enough here to remember that the putative cancer risk assessment  from chemical exposure is putative and not actual risk and as such full of uncertainty.

Wednesday, May 8, 2013

THE ACTUAL RISK POSED BY THE CHEMICALS WE ENCOUNTER EVERY DAY


Preliminary comments on blogging mechanics.

Many of the people that I most want to see this blog are on LinkedIn.   There are no auto buttons for linking to LinkedIn on Google blog so I had to learn how to find and insert some HTML code into the blog template to make that happen.    It seemed to work fine except that the process chopped off the title of the blog and it somehow killed the link to my web site while inserting a link to another unrelated web site over the text “risk assessment”.   I am not sure how to fix this but until I can fix it I will be putting the title in the first line of any subsequent blog and somewhere in there I will have my web site and this blog site spelled out.   Jayjock-associates.com   Jayjock-associates.blogspot.com

THE ACTUAL RISK POSED BY THE CHEMICALS WE ENCOUNTER EVERY DAY

In order to understand the risk from a chemical to human health, one needs to understand its toxicity.   That is, WHAT happens when you become overexposed to it (e.g., it damages your kidneys or lungs or brain, etc).   Indeed, every substance (even oxygen) is toxic given a high enough exposure while some chemicals are toxic at very low doses (e.g., bis-chloromethylether).   Once you know the toxicity you need to understand the level of actual human exposure to that chemical.   The simple equation is:

Risk = The integrated product of Toxicity and Exposure

You cannot even start a risk assessment without some knowledge of the toxicity of the chemical. Many folks assume that the chemicals we are exposed to have been tested for toxicity.   The fact of the matter is that in the vast majority of cases they have not.   For the most part, except for pesticides and chemicals which have proven themselves dangerous because people become frankly sick or died from exposure to them (e.g., benzene), there has been relatively little testing of their toxic effects.   Indeed, 16 year ago the Environmental Defense Fund issued a ground breaking report:  Toxic Ignorance  - http://www.edf.org/sites/default/files/243_toxicignorance_0.pdf.   

An excerpt from that document quotes even earlier work:  “In the early 1980s, the National Academy of Sciences’ National Research Council completed a four-year study and found that 78% of the chemicals in highest-volume commercial use had not had even "minimal" toxicity testing. Thirteen years later, there has been no significant improvement.”  Well now the clock is up to almost 30 years.

This turned out to be such a powerful message in 1997 that the EPA got involved and started the High Product Volume (HPV) challenge program in which companies would volunteer to test these chemicals.   From my perspective it is safe to say that this program has been evaluated by many as being not completely successful.   I am not familiar with the details but I do know that for most of the chemicals for which I go looking today for good toxicology data in order to make some decisions about the type of adverse health effect or its potency I come up empty.   There are literally tens of thousands of chemicals in our environment, mostly from the chemicals we as a society produce and use to make our life better.  The vast majority of these have no definitive or inadequate toxicity data on them.   

There are new attempts to fill this gap from a scientific (EPA ToxCast Screen) and a regulatory perspective (European REACh program) which I hope to discuss in a future blog.   In the meantime, I have an opinion relative to the title of this blog.   My sense is that the vast majority of chemicals that we use and are exposed to in our everyday lives are safe at the exposure levels that most of us encounter.  Thus, I do not think that we should be lying awake at night worrying about our exposures.   Having said this, please note that it is simply my opinion.   It is an opinion born of a professional lifetime working in this field; however it is important to realize that my opinion is NOT a risk assessment.    Also I am also almost certain that there are some (perhaps many) chemicals and some subpopulations of people whose exposures to those chemicals are dangerous but, at this point, they remain unevaluated and thus not controlled. I think most of this happens in the workplace but some may be happening in our homes.  Suffice it to say that without the data and subsequent risk assessments, the size of these subpopulations is unknown.  In short, a lot of regulatory/political and scientific work remains to be done to identify these situations and to protect these folks.